April 18, 2005 Extra Credit
Archived Information

  Subscribe, Unsubscribe  Share this page Share this page
April 18, 2005

Past Extra Credits
April 15
All issues
"No Child Left Behind Is … Better Than This Dog By Miles"

The following are excerpts from a recent op-ed in The Salt Lake Tribune by Jim Jenkin, a parent whose children go to school in the Salt Lake School District:

"In all their years of ‘showing who’s in charge’ and ideological chest-beating, however, the [Utah State] Legislature has never stooped to hurting children - until now. This time they will hurt children, lots of them. They will hurt them directly and hurt the ones who are in the most need. House Bill 135, the measure to opt out of No Child Left Behind (NCLB), damages children's education by turning back millions of dollars in federal funds that support education for the handicapped and the disadvantaged among Utah's school children.

"In Salt Lake District the loss is reported as $9.3 million, or just under $400 a child for the district’s 24,000 or so students. Under current tax laws, this money is irreplaceable. Maybe other districts are better off, maybe others are worse. It doesn’t matter - 24,000 casualties are more than enough to give anybody pause."

"The bill also would replace the burdensome NCLB mandatory reporting system, based on testing in two subjects, with a burdensome state system of mandatory reporting of testing in four subjects. So much for saving money. The bill also would impact procedures that allow educators to monitor the progress of the less-successful groups, thus removing the key reform of NCLB. The best kids will again be used to bring up the scores of the worst, and failure will once again be safely hidden.

"So, to recap, the bill’s sponsors have been so quick to jump on the states’ rights bandwagon that they’ve overlooked that they’re giving the feds back $110 million (which they propose to replace with a $63 million state surplus) and they’re increasing the reporting burden while eliminating a good portion of its effectiveness. We’re spending $63 million to lose $110 million for little or no benefit. No Child Left Behind is far from perfect but it’s better than this dog by miles.

"The primary point, however, is still that this bill hurts kids. There is no way you can take $8,000 to $10,000 out of a classroom and not hurt those kids’ education. Children are our future economic stability, our future caretakers and our hope for the future of America and the world. To degrade them is to degrade ourselves."

Note: Part II of Secretary Spellings’ recent testimony on lifelong learning before the Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions will be featured in an upcoming Extra Credit. Part I, which was featured in last Friday’s Extra Credit, is available online at:


About Extra Credit
NCLB Extra Credit is a regular look at the No Child Left Behind Act, President Bush's landmark education reform initiative passed with bipartisan support in Congress.

Subscribe to get the Extra Credit emailed to you.
Unsubscribe to stop receiving Extra Credit.

Print this page Printable view Send this page Share this page
Last Modified: 04/18/2005